Four competing schemes for Downtown Los Angeles’ First & Broadway Civic Park

Architecture City Terrain Landscape Architecture West

Mia Lehrer + Associates/ OMA/ IDEO scheme for First and Broadway Park (Courtesy OMA)

First there was the Grand Park, then Pershing Square decided to spruce things up with a design competition, and now four competing schemes for a third Downtown Los Angeles park were presented to the city in a public meeting this week. The proposals were from teams lead by AECOM, Brooks + Scarpa, Eric Owen Moss Architects, and Mia Lehrer + Associates with OMA and IDEO.

Brooks + Scarpa scheme for First and Broadway Park (Mimi Zeiger/ AN)

Brooks + Scarpa scheme for First and Broadway Park (Mimi Zeiger/ AN)

The two-acre First & Broadway Civic Park will take over a full block in the heart of the L.A.’s Civic Center near City Hall and the Gordon Kaufmann’s Art Deco Los Angeles Times building. The overall greening of Downtown Los Angeles is consistent with its ongoing renewal. As such, each of the teams provided ample amenities in the park—canopies, cafes, music venues, movie screens—in addition to the standard fare of gardens, trees, and benches.

AECOMmodel

AECOM’s proposal takes iconic modernist landscape architect Garrett Eckbo’s 1946 Landscape for Living as a starting point, and then updates his California dream to be a collective experience. Hints of fifties modernism show themselves in the irregularly shaped lawn, which is framed by “The Wingnut,” which houses a gallery, and a 200-seat restaurant “The Paper Plane.”

Brooks + Scarpa scheme for First and Broadway Park (Mimi Zeiger/ AN)

Brooks + Scarpa scheme for First and Broadway Park (Mimi Zeiger/ AN)

Undulating ribbons—green space above, amenities underneath—define Brooks + Scarpa‘s plan. The team suggests that the scheme is ecological with drought-minded plantings and integrated terraces and cisterns that lead to an expansive dry well. Hidden within the proposal is some programming sure to excite the design community: the Architecture and Urbanism Festival, a possible 3-month long curated event that would include temporary installations and public programs.

EOM event pavilion (Mimi Zeiger/ AN)

EOM event pavilion (Mimi Zeiger/ AN)

Eric Owen Moss Architects, never a firm to shy away from odd forms, proposed a large cocoon-like structure dominates a rolling and grassy green space. Ready to compete with the nearby crowning towers of City Hall and the Times, EOM’s event pavilion seems equipped to screen films and host events.

Mia Lehrer + Associates / OMA / IDEO food pavilion (Courtesy OMA)

Mia Lehrer + Associates powerhouse team also includes OMA, IDEO, and Arup, among others. Their proposal takes food as its design driver. While the scheme shows a central paved plaza and side gardens lush with alien-ish shade canopies and mature trees, the main emphasis is on a multi-use pavilion building that includes a beer garden, a test kitchen, a restaurant, and an amphitheater.

Presentation boards and models of the designs are on public display at the Department of Building and Safety at 201 North Figueroa.

Related Stories